DETERMINATIONS: 2001

JANUARY:
DETERMINATION DATE
R Schneeberger v South African Insurance Association Pension Fund and Southern Life Association 10/01/2001
Jannie Zeman v Sanlam Life Insurance Ltd, Sanlam Preservation Pension Fund and First National Bank Group Pension Fund 16/01/2001
Jannie Zeman v Sanlam Life Insurance Ltd, Sanlam Preservation Pension Fund and First National Bank Group Pension Fund (final) 07/02/2001
Mahlambi J M v Chubb Group Pension Fund 22/01/2001
Ellis R E NO v Lifestyle Retirement Annuity Fund 22/01/2001
Bruce D v Lifestyle Retirement Annuity Fund 23/01/2001
Lloyd Anthony Kolb v University of Natal Retirement Fund, University of Natal and Alexander Forbes Financial Services 23/01/2001
Louise Claire Lewis v First National Bank Group Pension Fund 25/01/2001
A M Griffiths, W H Swartz and H A Arrangie v Dromedaris Visserye BPK Pension Fund and Liberty Life Association of Africa Limited 26/01/2001
M F Oosthuizen v Nedcor Pension Fund 26/01/2001
Mark September v Edelweis Provident Fund, Edelweiss Glass and Aluminium cc and Liberty Life Limited 26/01/2001
Jose Pereira Pelicias v Unilever SA Pension Fund 29/01/2001
J Malanga v Group Five Multi Benefit Retirement Fund 31/01/2001
Vera Swanepoel v Central Retirement Annuity Fund and Vera Kelbrick 31/01/2001
FEBRUARY:
DETERMINATION DATE
Alistair Alexander Laurence v The Liquidator, International Retail Fashion Focus (IRFF) Retirement Plan 01/02/2001
Augustina Nxumalo v The Central Provident Fund and Sanlam Life Insurance Limited 01/02/2001
PWA Jansen van Vuuren & 10 Others v Municipal Employees Gratuity Fund 01/02/2001
B M Till v Unilever SA Pension Fund (Final) 01/02/2001
J G Moran v De Beers Pension Fund 02/02/2001
S E Sekele v The Orion Money Purchase Pension Fund (SA) and Bahwaduba Bus Service (Pty) Ltd 02/02/2001
L A Gafane v The Orion Money Purchase Pension Fund (SA) and Bahwaduba Bus Service (Pty) Ltd 06/02/2001
FPJ Greyling v OZZ Pension Fund 09/02/2001
S Moroe & 9 Others v AECI Employees Pension Fund, AECI Explosives Ltd and Chemical Workers Industrial Union 15/02/2001
A D Wasserman v Central Annuity Retirement Fund 23/02/2001
H C Rhode v University of the Western Cape Provident Fund and Old Mutual Life Assurance (SA) Ltd 27/02/2001
A R Kipling v Unilever SA Pension Fund 28/02/2001
K T Tshehla N.O. v Iscor Provident Fund 28/02/2001
A Koch v Fedsure Life Assurance Limited and South Bakels Provident Fund 28/02/2001
MARCH:
DETERMINATION DATE
Dugmore Khumalo v Coca Cola Canners Provident Fund, Liberty Life Associated of South Africa Ltd and Coca Cola Canners of South Africa Limited 01/03/2001
Annah Maepa v Sanlam Retirement Fund (Office Staff) 06/03/2001
Andre Kruger and IMATU Retirement Fund 07/03/2001
M Mwelase v Randcoal Provident Fund 07/03/2001
S Sablay & Others v FNB Pension Fund and Personal Wealth Preserver Pension Fund 07/03/2001
Martha Sebela v Senwes Limited Pension Fund 07/03/2001
E Erasmus v Johannesburg Chamber of Commerce & Industry Pension Fund, South African Chamber of Business and Capital Alliance Holdings Limited 07/03/2001
N Isaacs v SAMA Pension Fund and SAMA Health & Medical Publishing Group 16/03/2001
J G Moran v De Beers Pension Fund 16/03/2001
Jannie Zeman v Sanlam Life Insurance Ltd, Sanlam Preservation Pension Fund and First National Bank Group Pension Fund 19/03/2001
Jimmie de Ruiter v Bosal Afrika Pension Fund, Bosal Afrika (Pty)Ltd and Old Mutual 27/03/2001
Louise Claire Lewis v First National Bank Group Pension Fund 27/03/2001
John Chalmers v Nedcor Pension Fund and Nedcor Defined Contribution Provident Fund 30/03/2001
APRIL:
DETERMINATION DATE
E P Schoeman v Rentmeester Pensioenfonds 02/04/2001
S Sablay & Others v FNB Pension Fund and Personal Wealth Preserver Pension Fund 06/04/2001
A R Kipling v Unilever SA Pension Fund and Karen Dettmer 06/04/2001
K Fullarton v Buckman Laboratories (Pty) Ltd and Buckman Laboratories (Pty) Ltd Provident Fund 06/04/2001
S R Bona v South African Local Authorities Fund and Old Mutual Life Assurance Limited 10/04/2001
P E Saaiman v Superflex Preservation Fund and Multirand Imvestment Solutions Limited 10/04/2001
J F C le Roux v Sanlam Retirement Fund 10/04/2001
N Lehujo v Airports Company Pension Fund 11/04/2001
G P Hunt v Liebherr-Africa Managed Pension Plan and Liebherr-Africa (Pty) Ltd 11/04/2001
P Damgaard v EAC Provident 11/04/2001
Johannes Modupe v Welkom Stationers and Printers Midas Pension Plan and Welkom Printers and Printers (Pty)Ltd 17/04/2001
Lucas Mojahi & Others v Gauteng Building Industrial Retirement Fund and Grinaker Building Transvaal (Pty) Ltd 17/04/2001
Augustina Nxumalo v The Central Provident Fund and Sanlam Life Insurance Limited 17/04/2001
CALA Dairies CC v Orion Money Purchase Provident Fund and Old Mutual Life Assurance Company Limited 17/04/2001
Wendy Ann Leak v Commercial Union of South Africa Staff Pension Fund and Commercial Union Life Asurance Company of South Africa Ltd (now Metropolitan Life) 20/04/2001
V Govender v Alpha Group Employees Provident Fund and Aploon Wilson 26/04/2001
J P Karam v Amrel Provident Fund 26/04/2001
Z L Magwaza v B B Cereals Provident Fund 26/04/2001
S S Phashe & Others v Metro Group Retirement Fund 26/04/2001
MAY:
DETERMINATION DATE
G Thomas v Furman Glass Provident Fund and Furman Glass (Pty) Ltd 02/05/2001
E M Sefako v First National Bank Group Pension Fund 02/05/2001
P Ditshabe v Sanlam Marketers Retirement Fund 03/05/2001
L Robinson v Central Retirement Annuit Fund 03/05/2001
J Tlaka v Abbott Laboratories Pension Fund 07/05/2001
Louise Claire Lewis v First National Bank Group Pension Fund 07/05/2001
G Thomas v Furman Glass Provident Fund and Furman Glass (Pty)Ltd 10/05/2001
Johannes Modupe v Welkom Stationers and Printers Midas Pension Plan and Welkom Stationers and Printers (Pty)Ltd 11/05/2001
O T le Roux v Child Welfare Provident Fund 14/05/2001
S S Khambule v CNA Ltd, now CNA (Pty)Ltd; CNA GALLO (1990) Provident Fund, now Millenium Entertainment Group Africa Ltd Fund and CNA Provident Fund 17/05/2001
Whealan & Others v Babcock Africa Pension Fund and The Registrar of Pension Funds 21/05/2001
J L Provan v Liberty Life Association of Africa Limited and Huco Retirement Scheme 22/05/2001
Epol Pension Fund v Premier Retirement Fund 24/05/2001
Glen Spear v IBM SA 1994 Provident Fund and IBM SA (Pty)Ltd 24/05/2001
C Twigg v Orion Money Purchase Pension Fund and Rubber Rollers (Pty)Ltd 28/05/2001
Merz&McLellan (South Africa) Pension Scheme v Monmentum Employee Benefits (Pty)Ltd 28/05/2001
JFC le Roux v Sanlam Retirement Fund 29/05/2001
JUNE:
DETERMINATION DATE
Z L Magwaza v BB Cereals Provident Fund,S Nsibande and P Nsibande 19/06/2001
A J P du Preez v Joint Municipal Pension Fund 19/06/2001
C A T Kuipers v Municipal Employees Gratuity Fund and Joint Municipal Pension Fund 19/06/2001
P Zulu v Illovo Sugar Provident Fund 20/06/2001
E Swanepoel v Mine Officials Pension Fund and Sage Pension Preservation Fund 20/06/2001
I Booysen and S Vleermuis v Central Retirement Annuity Fund 20/06/2001
L Robinson v Central Retirement Annuity Fund and Orna Koch (previously Greeff) 20/06/2001
O T le Roux v Child Welfare Provident Fund and Johannesburg Child Welfare Society 20/06/2001
L G J Fourie v Orion Fixed Benefit Pension Fund (SA) and Houwhoek Trust (Wilderkrans) 20/06/2001
W G Steele v Foschini Group Retirement Fund 20/06/2001
Stephanus Johannes Roos v OVS Nywerhede Pensioen Fonds and Bethlehem Motors (Pty)Ltd 20/06/2001
Jack Nicholas Phillips v Johannesburg Municipal Pension Fund and Metropolitan Bus Company (Pty)Ltd 21/06/2001
Carel Johannes Venter v Santam Retirement Fund 21/06/2001
Kosam Legari v Pep Retirement Fund and Pep Limited 22/06/2001
Matthew Murray v The Wealth Builder Pension Preservation Fund 22/06/2001
JULY:
DETERMINATION DATE
W F Wormald v Iscor Pension Fund and Iscor Benefit Fund 02/07/2001
Merz & McLellan (South Africa) Pension Scheme v Momentum Employee Benefits (Pty)Ltd 02/07/2001
CALA Dairies cc v Orion Money Purchase Provident Fund and Old Mutual Life Assurance Company Limited 02/07/2001
M H Harilall v Maxirand Provident Fund 02/07/2001
F V Bowes v AECI Pension Fund 02/07/2001
E M Sefako v First National Bank Group Pension Fund 03/07/2001
K W Diergaardt v KWV-Voorsorgfonds 03/07/2001
F Daniels v Crown Cork Pension Fund, Crown Cork Company (SA) (Pty) Ltd and Crown Cork Provident Fund 05/07/2001
Jan Christiaan Pienaar v Consol Group Pension Fund (Pty)Ltd, Consol Group Life Assurance and Disability Scheme and Consol Limited 11/07/2001
B E Mellet v The Orion Money Purchase Pension Fund (SA) and Jacobsohn & Mellet Isurance Brokers (Pty)Ltd 16/07/2001
F Matthew Murray v The Wealth Builder Pension Preservation Fund 16/07/2001
W G Steele v Foschini Group Retirement Plan v Galaxy Preservation Fund 16/07/2001
H M S Ankers v Amalgam Pension Fund, Tone Graphics cc and J C Crook NO 16/07/2001
B C Black v Corporate Selection Retirement Fund 17/07/2001
C M Adams v African Oxygen Limited Pension Fund and African Oxygen Limited 17/07/2001
Mark Bester and Karin Bester v Central Retirement Annuity Fund 17/07/2001
V Govender v Alpha Group Employees Provident Fund and Aploon Wilson 18/07/2001
Desmond V. Fernhold v Aranda Textiles Pension Fund and Roxburgh Benefit Concultants 18/07/2001
J E Zikhali and N A Zikhali v Metal Industries Provident Fund 19/07/2001
B J Moat v Standard Bank Group Riterement Fund 20/07/2001
H van der Walt v Clothing Industry (Natal) Provident Fund and Bargaining Council for the Clothing Industry, Natal 20/07/2001
L M Seymour v Clinic Holdings Executive Retirement Fund 23/07/2001
B E Manzini v Metro Group Retirement Fund and Metcash Trading Limited 23/07/2001
Johann C J Nothnagel v MISA Pension Fund and The Motor Industry Fund Administrators (Pty)Ltd 27/07/2001
Stephanus J Roos v OVS Nywerhede Pensioen Fonds and Bethlehem Motors (Pty)Ltd 27/07/2001
J Vogt v Rennies Group Pension Fund and Old Mutual Employee Benefits 30/07/2001
AUGUST:
DETERMINATION DATE
Olive Mokoatle v Commercial Industries National Provident Fund, Kashgar CC and African Life Assurance Company Limited 01/08/2001
R Bhartu v Metal & Engineering Industries Permanent Disability Scheme 01/08/2001
B L Welch v Golden Pension Fund 01/08/2001
P A Records v Barlows Pension Fund 02/08/2001
Patrick Thompson v Tibbet & Britten Retirement Plan and Tibbet & Britten SA(Pty)Ltd 02/08/2001
C J Potgieter v Metal & Engineering Industries Permanent Disability Scheme 06/08/2001
Leslie Strassburg v Telkom Retirement Fund and Cheryl Strassburg 06/08/2001
HTN v Municipal Gratuity Fund 06/08/2001
S E L Sekul v Seventh-Day Adventist Church Pension Fund 07/08/2001
P Ditshabe v Sanlam Marketers' Retirement Fund 08/08/2001
R Rambaran v SA Typographical Union Pension Fund 15/08/2001
M Jones v National Technikon Retirement Fund 16/08/2001
M Mashilo v Basil Read Group Provident Fund 17/08/2001
EA Fourie v Free State Municipal Pension Fund 17/08/2001
MP Mudzusi v Hospitality Industry Provident Fund 20/08/2001
B L Welch v Golden Pension Fund 23/08/2001
H Harilall v Maxirand Provident Fund 23/08/2001
Butana Edward Manzini v Metro Group Retirement Fund 24/08/2001
Oliveia J Aherne v Hortors Group Pension Fund 24/08/2001
M Naidoo v The New Republic Bank Retirement Fund 27/08/2001
S S Khambule v CNA Ltd 27/08/2001
Moses Mohlamme v African Bank Pension Fund 28/08/2001
M M Matsobane & Others v Cape Gate Negotiated Provident Fund 28/08/2001
GP Naidoo v Printflex Pension Fund  28/08/2001
KS Ngoepe v Metal Industries Provident Fund 28/08/2001
Thabang Isaac Mabuya v SA Druggists Provident Fund 28/08/2001
B J Moat v Standard Bank Group Retirement Fund 29/08/2001
W M Sebola v Johnson Tiles (Pty) Ltd 29/08/2001
G A Alder v Anglo American Group Pension Fund 29/08/2001
VA Mes v Liquidator of Art Medical Equipment Pension Fund 29/08/2001
Express Petroleum Midas Pension Plan v Metropolitan Life Ltd 29/08/2001
P Naidoo v N Salie N.O. 29/08/2001
Olive Mokoatle v Commercial Industries National Provident Fund 30/08/2001
SEPTEMBER:
DETERMINATION DATE
Cassim Vally v Federal Mogul Pension Fund 04/09/2001
J Hooley v Haggie Pension Fund 05/09/2001
J Thema v Metal Industries Provident Fund 06/09/2001
N Kubayi v Protektor Pension Preservation Fund 06/09/2001
A Kleynhans v Municipal Gratuity Fund 06/09/2001
Joyce van Dyk v Fedsure Life Assurance Ltd 10/09/2001
K Magane v Engineering Industries Pension Fund 10/09/2001
E Swanepoel v Mine Officials Pension Fund 17/09/2001
G Seloane & Others v Ledeen Provident Fund 17/09/2001
M T Connery v Old Mutual Life Assurance Co 17/09/2001
C Szalek v Iscor Pension Fund 18/09/2001
K S Ngoepe v Metal Industries Provident Fund 18/09/2001
M N Ntshangase v Frame Group Provident Fund 18/09/2001
S E L Sekul v Seventh-Day Adventist Church Pension Fund 18/09/2001
I Dlavana, M Rammutle v Shoprite Checkers Employees Retirement Fund 19/09/2001
G A Alder v Anglo American Group Pension Fund 20/09/2001
G Lamparelli v Eskom Pension Fund 27/09/2001
J P Franken v Sage Life Staff Pension Fund 27/09/2001
S E Liebenberg v Municipal Gratuity Fund 28/09/2001
G P Hunt v Liebherr-Africa Managed Pension Plan 28/09/2001
T M Kingsburgh v Vitria Glass Products 28/09/2001
OCTOBER:
DETERMINATION DATE
X Ndongeni v Orion Money Purchase Provident Fund 02/10/2001
Whelan & Others v Babcock Africa Pension Fund 03/10/2001
William M Sebola v Johnson Tiles (Pty) Ltd 05/10/2001
P Mkaba v SA Breweries Staff Provident Fund 08/10/2001
G Seloane & Others v Ledeen Provident Fund 08/10/2001
David Walwyn v AECI Pension Fund 08/10/2001
James Botha v Academy Brushware Retirement Fund 09/10/2001
N M Mangxiki v Mineworkers Provident Fund 09/10/2001
KCBH v Federated Timbers (Pty) Ltd 09/10/2001
P Naicker v Orion Money Purchase Pension Fund (SA) 11/10/2001
T Ndlovu v The Vegmoflora Fund 12/10/2001
Oliveia J Aherne v Hortors Group Pension Fund 15/10/2001
G Flemming v Motor Industry Pension Fund 17/10/2001
H v/d Walt v Clothing Industry (Natal) Prov. Fund 17/10/2001
Julian Hitchcock v Johnnies Pension Fund 19/10/2001
Cassim Vally v Federal Mogul Pension Fund 22/10/2001
C Twigg v Orion Money Purchase Pension Fund 22/10/2001
HMS Ankers v Amalgam Pension Fund 24/10/2001
R Harker & Others v Simba Provident Fund 24/10/2001
D Baloyi v Denel Retirement Fund 25/10/2001
D A Gemmell, C H Pieterse v Independent Retirement Annuity Fund + TMA Investment Products Services 26/10/2001
H v Otis (SA) Pension Fund 30/10/2001
Final: S E Liebenberg v Municipal Gratuity Fund 30/10/2001
Prelim: P Olivier v Mine Employees Pension Fund 31/10/2001
Prelim: M P Manyoni v Metal Industries Provident Fund 31/10/2001
NOVEMBER:
DETERMINATION DATE
Final: K Magane v Engineering Industries Pension Fund 1/11/2001
M M Nkosi v Chemical Industries National Provident Fund 1/11/2001
R A Phillips v Avtex Retirement Fund 1/11/2001
Prelim: Hollywood Display Employees v SACCAWU Nat. Provident Fund 2/11/2001
M J Convery v Hudaco Industries Group Retirement Fund 5/11/2001
F B Thulo v Metropolitan Staff Pension Fund 6/11/2001
G Hattingh v Central Retirement Annuity Fund 7/11/2001
A B Nicol, R H C Small v The Sage Pension Fund 13/11/2001
T S Ehlers v Nedcor Defined Contribution Provident Fund 13/11/2001
T M Kingsburgh v Vitria Glass Products 13/11/2001
D Hiebner v Metal + Engineering Permanent Disability Scheme 15/11/2001
B P SA Provident Fund v BP SA Pension Fund 15/11/2001
J van Veenhuyzen v ABSA Group Pension Fund 15/11/2001
S Allie v Southern Staff Pension Fund 16/11/2001
J D Ferrao v Liberty Life Pension Fund 16/11/2001
B E Mellet v Orion Money Purchase Pension Fund 16/11/2001
H S Biermann v ABSA Consultants + Actuaries, Pensioenfonds v.d. UOVS + University OFS 16/11/2001
Joyce van Dyk v Fedsure Life Assurance Ltd 16/11/2001
AR van den Heever v Cape Joint Retirement Fund 19/11/2001
Final: KCBH v Federated Timbers, PPWAWU Provident Fund + Fedsure Life Ass. 20/11/2001
Prelim: G Spear v IBM SA 1994 Provident Fund + IBM SA 20/11/2001
M C Wagener v PG Group Provident Fund 21/11/2001
M P Mudzusi vs Hospitality Industry Provident Fund 20/11/2001
R Nkosi vs Registrar of Pension Funds + Acrytex Retirement Fund 22/11/2001
Hollywood Display Employees vs SACCAWU National Provident Fund 26/11/2001
Isaac Dlavana vs Shoprite Checkers + Old Mutual Life Assurance 29/11/2001
C J Potgieter vs Metal + Eng. Ind. Permanent Disability Scheme 30/11/2001
N R Mbokazi vsTextile + Allied Workers Provident Fund 30/11/2001
D M Malesa vs African Bank Pension Fund + Others 30/11/2001
DECEMBER:
DETERMINATION DATE
K J Mabokela vs Southern Staff Pension Fund 4/12/2001
L A Cilliers vs Kagiso Khulani Pension Fund 5/12/2001
P Maimela vs Simba Provident Fund 5/12/2001
A M E Steyn vs The NGK Officials Pension Fund 5/12/2001
M Mohlamme vs African Bank Pension Fund + Others 5/12/2001
M T Connery vs Old Mutual Life Assurance Co + Rumdel Retirement Fund 5/12/2001
W F Wormald vs Iscor Pension Fund 5/12/2001
ND Emma & Others vs Orion Money Purchase Provident Fund 6/12/2001